Listen to Jesus Was An Alien online. Jesus Was An Alien is an English language song and is sung by Tabitha's Secret. Jesus Was An Alien, from the album Don't Play With Matches - Tabitha's Secret With Rob Thomas, Jay Stanley, Brian Yale, Paul Doucette and John Goff, was released in the year 2010. The duration of the song is 4:38. Download English songs online from JioSaavn.