Season 4 is halfway through! We have a puzzling case for you this time. Who murdered Michael Johnston and his secret girlfriend That Chelle Robinson? Almost 3 decades ago, on a summer morning, the body of 25-year-old Michael was found by Rochelle's car on an isolated road in Pierce County, WA. Only hours later, Rochelle would also be found deceased, nearly 5 miles away. The case was cold before it even started. But over the years, there have been speculations from psychics, possible ties to the occult, and a stalker named "the pimply man" connected to this case.But no one has been brought to justice.This episode is a special guest (or two!), joining in for the discussion on this case and what could have happened.Information from this episodeReddit has a lot to say about thishttps://bit.ly/3oqIHKGhttps://bit.ly/3gn73RaNews of the deathshttps://bit.ly/3sfYywBhttps://bit.ly/3J0x58Whttps://bit.ly/3J0x58Whttps://bit.ly/3sfYywBUnsolved Mysteries won’t speak of Magic: The Gatheringhttps://bit.ly/3ojnja7https://bit.ly/3ulWiGRhttps://bit.ly/34hnqftEven Sylvia Brown had thoughts, and people had thoughts about herhttps://bit.ly/3AVihpc25+ years laterhttps://bit.ly/3ojnyC3https://bit.ly/3L239Lo